Managing SMSF Death Benefits to Avoid Conflict

Payment of superannuation death benefits is one of the most sensitive and legally complex aspects of estate planning.

For SMSF advisers, it’s also one of the most common sources of conflict. Without clear, binding nominations and alignment with the client’s broader estate plan, disputes can arise. This results in delaying distributions, damaging family relationships, and increasing legal risk.

Over the years, I’ve seen how easily superannuation death benefits can become a source of family conflict.

Often not because of bad intentions, but because the planning was unclear or incomplete.

In this article, I’m sharing the key strategies I use when working with advisers to help their SMSF clients avoid unnecessary disputes.

From choosing the right kind of nomination to making sure it lines up with the Will, these steps are practical, preventative, and built on experience.

1. Educate Clients on the Importance of Superannuation Death Benefits

• Why it matters: Many clients may not fully understand the role superannuation plays in their estate planning or the potential for disputes over death benefits.
• How advisers can help:
  • Take time to explain how superannuation death benefits work and how the funds will be distributed upon death.
  • Discuss the various types of beneficiaries (e.g., spouse, dependent children, legal personal representative) and how each one is treated under superannuation law

2. Encourage Binding Death Benefit Nominations (BDBN)

• Why it matters: A BDBN is the most effective way to ensure the superannuation death benefit is distributed according to the client’s wishes.
• How advisers can help:
  • Guide clients through the process of completing a BDBN and ensure they understand the rules for valid nominations (e.g., nomination must be signed, witnessed, and renewed every three years).
  • Ensure that the nomination aligns with the client’s overall estate plan and objectives.
  • Keep track of the nomination’s expiration dates and remind clients to renew it as needed.

See: How to align BDBNs with the trust deed.

3. Ensure Nominations Are Consistent with the Client’s Will

• Why it matters: If a client’s superannuation death benefit nomination contradicts their will, it could cause confusion or conflict.
• How advisers can help:
  • Review both the superannuation nomination and the client’s will to ensure consistency.
  • Advise clients to ensure their will includes provisions for the treatment of superannuation death benefits (e.g., nominating their legal personal representative to handle the super death benefit if it’s directed to the estate).
  • Collaborate with the client’s solicitor to align their estate plan with their superannuation nominations.

4. Discuss and Document the Client’s Wishes

• Why it matters: Disputes often arise from misunderstandings or lack of communication about the client’s intentions.
• How advisers can help:
  • Have in-depth conversations with clients about who they want to benefit from their superannuation death benefits and why.
  • Document the client’s wishes and, if appropriate, share these with the client’s family members, so everyone is clear on the decisions.
  • Encourage clients to prepare a letter of wishes to accompany their superannuation nomination, providing context and clarifying their intentions to beneficiaries.

5. Regularly Review and Update Superannuation Plans

• Why it matters: Clients’ personal situations can change over time. Marriage, divorce, birth of children, or changing relationships with family members can all affect who should receive superannuation death benefits.
• How advisers can help:
  • Set up a regular review process to revisit the client’s superannuation death benefit nominations and overall estate plan.
  • Prompt clients to update their nominations and review their beneficiaries after major life events (e.g., marriage, divorce, children reaching adulthood).

6. Clarify the Risks of Non-Binding Nominations

• Why it matters: Non-binding death benefit nominations leave the decision to the trustee of the superannuation fund, which can cause delays or disputes if the trustee’s decision is contested.
• How advisers can help:
  • Advise clients on the potential pitfalls of non-binding nominations, especially if their family dynamics are complex.
  • Educate clients on how non-binding nominations may cause disputes, particularly if the trustee’s decision doesn’t align with the client’s wishes.

7. Mitigate Potential Family Conflicts

• Why it matters: Family disputes often arise when a beneficiary feels excluded or unfairly treated.
• How advisers can help:
  • Encourage clients to discuss their superannuation death benefit nominations with their family members to prevent misunderstandings.
  • Guide clients in choosing beneficiaries who are likely to avoid conflict (e.g., focusing on immediate family members rather than extended family).
  • In some cases, recommend family mediation or professional counseling to address deeper family issues that might cause conflict.

8. Ensure the Right Beneficiaries Are Nominated

• Why it matters: Superannuation funds can only pay benefits to eligible beneficiaries (spouses, dependents, or the legal personal representative). If the wrong person is nominated, the fund may not honor the request, and the estate may be subject to legal challenges.
• How advisers can help:
  • Clarify the eligibility requirements for superannuation beneficiaries and ensure clients nominate those who are eligible (spouses, children, financial dependents).
  • Advise clients on the impact of relationships such as de facto partners, estranged partners, or blended families.

9. Work with Legal and Estate Planning Professionals

• Why it matters: Financial advisers may not always have the legal expertise to manage complex estate issues, especially when it involves superannuation funds.
• How advisers can help:
  • Collaborate with solicitors and estate planners to ensure the client’s superannuation death benefits are integrated into a cohesive estate plan.
  • Involve estate lawyers in drafting wills that consider superannuation death benefits, ensuring that the client’s superannuation fund is treated in accordance with their overall wishes.

10. Advocate for Professional Trustees Where Necessary

• Why it matters: Disputes can arise when family members are appointed as trustees, particularly if there’s a conflict of interest or differing interpretations of the client’s wishes.
• How advisers can help:
  • In cases where there’s risk of family conflict, suggest appointing an independent trustee or professional executor who can impartially manage the distribution of the death benefits.
  • Provide guidance on how to establish clear guidelines for trustees in the event of disputes

11. Provide Ongoing Support After the Client’s Death

• Why it matters: Even with proper planning, disputes may still arise after a client’s death, and the family may require support in executing the client’s wishes.
• How advisers can help:
  • Be available to help the client’s family navigate the superannuation death benefit claims process.
  • Offer assistance in dealing with any disputes or complications that arise after the client’s death, ensuring beneficiaries receive the support they need.

By taking a proactive and comprehensive approach, financial advisers can help clients reduce the risk of superannuation death benefit disputes, ensuring their wishes are respected and minimizing emotional and financial stress for their families.

Need support aligning superannuation strategies with estate planning?

Our team helps advisers manage complex client cases with confidence. Contact us and we will get back to you within one business day, or just give us a call.